bureau42.com      

bureau42.com email
Check your mail, or get a free address

Add to Google

part of the everyone.net Entertainment Network

Dreamhost Web Hosting

Problems with the site? Comments? Questions? Let us know!

 
welcome to bureau42.com
 
Star Trek: Enterprise - "Extinction"
posted September 29 2003, 9:00 am by theangrymob

Category: Star Trek

Apparently this is a Star Trek spin-off. I didn't know either.


Read more... ( 20 comments already posted ) | ( 4853 bytes in body ) | ( Post a comment )


<< Alias Review: The Two  | Post a comment | Jake 2.0 Discussion - "Arms and the Girl" >>

Extinction

Cast & Crew

Director: LeVar Burton
Written By: Andre Bormanis

Starring
Scott Bakula as Captain Jonathan Archer
Connor Trinneer as Chief Engineer Charles "Trip" Tucker III
Jolene Blalock as Sub-commander T'Pol
Dominic Keating as Lt. Malcolm Reed
Anthony Montgomery as Ensign Travis Mayweather
Linda Park as Ensign Hoshi Sato
John Billingsley as Dr. Phlox

Guest Cast
Philip Boyd as Com Officer
Roger Cross as Tret
Daniel Dae Kim as Corporal Chang
Troy Mittleider as Palmer
Brian J. Williams as Alien Decon Agent

Episode Information

Originally Aired: September 24, 2003
Season: Three
Episode: Three
Production: 055

What Happened

Their ongoing quest for the Xindi leads the Enterprise crew to a tropical alien world where Archer, Reed and Hoshi are exposed to a highly contagious virus that transforms their bodies and minds into those of the long extinct alien inhabitants of the planet.

Review

Despite what I thought going into the episode (i.e. a horribly misleading trailer), I liked this one better than most. Overall, it showed imagination and some creativity. I think we were all expecting to see "Threshold" from Voyager and got something closer to "Inner Light" from Next Generation. And if you're going to rip off old Trek, do it from the best.

High Point

And you thought peaches were only good for watching sexy women eat. We'll show you!

Low Point

The ending was a little lame. The ship's been in service for how long and they never think to use the transporter?

The Scores

Originality: Despite what we were shown on the preview, the fact that the mutation was designed to restore an alien race was quite clever. Something we haven't seen on Enterprise. 4 out of 6.

Effects: The alien civilization and the internal body transformations were cool. 5 out of 6.

Story: At least the story didn't dwell on the process of transformation (which has been done to death), but rather, on the consequences and the why. 4 out of 6.

Acting: I can see Burton's directing queues for this one: "Scott, squat down and run about. No, no! More ape-like. There you go!" 3 out of 6.

Emotional Response: Guys running around with flamethrowers always make me a touch edgy. It added a nice amount of tension to the story. 4 out of 6.

Production: Caves? But at least the make-up was interesting. 4 out of 6

Overall: While the episode was interesting, it didn't forward the overall plot of finding the Xindi. It could have been shelved for later or run last season. Get to the story that was promised over and over this summer. 4 out of 6.

Total: 28 out of 42

Episode Media

From StarTrek.com

Next Time on Enterprise (October 1, 2003)

Rajiin

Rescued by Archer from an alien bazaar, a captivating slave girl, Rajiin, uses her erotic, hypnotic mental powers on the crew to steal data on humans for her Xindi overlords. But when her deception is discovered, Archer throws her in the brig, forcing the Reptilian Xindi to storm the ship, weapons blazing, to spring her free.

Meanwhile, Trip and T'Pol initiate a dangerous experiment to insulate the ship from further destruction from strange physical phenomena in the Delphic Expanse.Video Preview

Additional Notes and Comments

If you're interested in what's in TheAngryMob's review queue, check out my What's Coming page.

TheAngrymob



 Comments

ugghh...
posted by is on September 29 2003, 10:12 am
There wasn't much good about this one.
I can't think of anything that really stood out to me. Too bad.

reply to this

Director
posted by jbrecken on September 29 2003, 10:23 am
It struck me as extremely appropriate that they got LeVar Burton to direct this, since he'd played the same scenario as an actor. The only difference is that these people didn't get to be invisible, too.

reply to this

Problems
posted by pdavis on September 29 2003, 11:21 am

I was so close to not watching this episode at all due to the trailer. The trailer was very misleading and the episode turned out to be much different than I had anticipated. However, I did have several points to pick with the writers...

1) Bridge Crew: Here we go again with sending the main bridge crew down to an unknown planet without any enviornmental protection. What, is the captain retarded? How about sending one officer and a few marines? In environmental suits? Hello? Anyone home in the writing department?

2) Medical: On another note, the doctor would have DNA samples for the entire crew. Period, end of story. I wouldn't doubt that the doctor would also have in stasis blood and tisue samples as well.

3)Transporter: Hate it, love it. All right, you trust it enough for non living things. I can deal with that. But they shouldn't rely on it to get the main characters out of trouble.


reply to this

Re: Problems
posted by joeshabazz on September 30 2003, 11:14 pm
1) Bridge Crew: Here we go again with sending the main bridge crew down to an unknown planet without any enviornmental protection. What, is the captain retarded? How about sending one officer and a few marines? In environmental suits? Hello? Anyone home in the writing department?

Hello, if you send a few marines then theres no story, who the hell cares about a few marines or one bloody officer, if the captains taken out then it's a big deal. Welcome to our little friend we like to call "plot device" sometime you have to pretend like your retarded in order to not hate all TV

reply to this

Re: Low Point
posted by dcheesi on September 29 2003, 11:41 am
Low Point

The ending was a little lame. The ship's been in service for how long and they never think to use the transporter?

I thought they mentioned that they couldn't risk the transporter? It sounded like they haven't invented "biofilters" yet (or direct point-to-point transfers to Isolation). Or were you referring to another point in the show?

Anyway, my low point was the rapid transformation of the team. There's no way a virus could rearrange their bone structure that fast.


reply to this

Re: Low Point
posted by vanyel on September 29 2003, 12:19 pm

Anyway, my low point was the rapid transformation of the team. There's no way a virus could rearrange their bone structure that fast.

I agree, I'm getting tired of this sort of thing. While superficially similar to Inner Light, this was far far FAR from being anywhere near as good (Inner Light, in fact, is probably my favorite Trek episode of all the series). I will admit to not giving enough credit to the reason for the virus, but I was probably blinded by the monkey acts, which was just silly.


reply to this

Re: Low Point
posted by Trekkie on September 29 2003, 1:37 pm
(Inner Light, in fact, is probably my favorite Trek episode of all the series).

Inner light is almost one of my favorite episodes of any television show that has aired on the light box we call television. Absolutely amazing to me. Had me sold on Patrick Stewart as an actor too. can't slobber enough with my praise on that single episode.


reply to this

Re: Low Point
posted by nkuzmik on October 1 2003, 6:00 am
(Inner Light, in fact, is probably my favorite Trek episode of all the series).

Inner light is almost one of my favorite episodes of any television show that has aired on the light box we call television. Absolutely amazing to me. Had me sold on Patrick Stewart as an actor too. can't slobber enough with my praise on that single episode.

Refresh my college addled mind, which epp is that?

reply to this

Re: Low Point
posted by Kaki on October 3 2003, 10:01 am
Refresh my college addled mind, which epp is that?
The one in which a probe from the, formerly living, now long-dead, world Kataan quick-feeds Picard a lifetime spent living there as Kamin, with a wife, friends, children and grandchildren (after Picard accepts his new life), and community involvement.

Here is a review of it.


reply to this

Re: Low Point
posted by jbrecken on September 30 2003, 5:37 am
Anyway, my low point was the rapid transformation of the team. There's no way a virus could rearrange their bone structure that fast.
They actually accounted for that. There was a scene where Phlox says that the laws of biology could be working as weird as the laws of physics did in those other anomalies.

reply to this

Next: SEX SEX SEX!
posted by usscaverns on September 29 2003, 12:16 pm
Next on Star Trek Enterprise: Alien Sex Slaves! Sex with Archer! Lesbian Action with Hoshi and T'Pol!

heh heh just kidding... that would be stupid...

Oh wait, no, I'm not kidding...


reply to this

Re: Next: SEX SEX SEX!
posted by Boglin on September 29 2003, 1:56 pm
Hey, if they're going to keep continuity with TOS, Archer is going to have to hook up with the alien women sooner or later. Kirk couldn't have pulled it off without at least some tradition to fall on.

reply to this

Re: Next: SEX SEX SEX!
posted by usscaverns on September 29 2003, 2:34 pm
Hey, if they're going to keep continuity with TOS, Archer is going to have to hook up with the alien women sooner or later. Kirk couldn't have pulled it off without at least some tradition to fall on.
That never seemed realistic to me. Even worse was Tripp and Malcolms panty-raid on Risa. I mean, how do they know these aliens don't have ridges on their foreheads and teeth in their privates?! They were lucky they were just shape-shifters!

Tz'aa-Clunk: "How was your date?"
Zk-sss-Click: "How could I know humans male sex organs don't produce acid resistant mucous? Who ever heard of such a thing?!"

reply to this

Re: Next: SEX SEX SEX!
posted by Timeshredder on September 30 2003, 3:58 am
Tz'aa-Clunk: "How was your date?"
Zk-sss-Click: "How could I know humans male sex organs don't produce acid resistant mucous? Who ever heard of such a thing?!"

Further proof we should be writing Enterprise!


reply to this

The Trailer.
posted by Trekkie on September 29 2003, 1:39 pm
The trailer for this episode was such a piece of crap compared to what it was really about.

I thought, from the trailer, that this episode found some stranded weird looking race that was actually some offshoot of enterprise that had crash landed their years ago. Some type of time-warp a la DS9 but with psycho mutations.

It wasn't a terrible episode, but it wasn't good either. Smallville gets recorded first Wednesday and the Saturday re-run takes second. TiVo #2 will record that 70s show for a while unless it's suddenly started sucking.


reply to this

Re: The Trailer.
posted by PianoComp81 on October 1 2003, 9:21 pm
The trailer for this episode was such a piece of crap compared to what it was really about.

I thought, from the trailer, that this episode found some stranded weird looking race that was actually some offshoot of enterprise that had crash landed their years ago. Some type of time-warp a la DS9 but with psycho mutations.

That's about what I thought, too. It DID say that an Enterprise crew had already landed (at least that's what I heard when watching the preview). Glad it wasn't that. The trailer for the Oct. 8 episode better be misleading as well! The preview for it was horrible

reply to this

Peaches
posted by mbourgon on September 30 2003, 7:28 am
If that was really the high point, howzabout including _that_ as the media? No interest in watching, but my curiosity has been piqued.

reply to this

Survival of the fittest? No DNAing it!
posted by SciFi0964 on October 1 2003, 2:15 pm
I found this episode interesting for a few reasons despite a previous themed story:

- Acting by the two of the three landing party was interesting. The makeup made them all but unrecognizable. The manerisms they utilized were... deferent. Bakula really surprised me in this role, who knew he had more range?

- No shoot em ups with a new race; instead they tried to avoid a fight.

- The reasoning of a race with a militant view and the inference as to why they have taken this view with regards to the virus.

On the down side I was dissapointed with other aspects of the story such as...

- Archer does not destroy the virus for the sake of propiety; even though it ravaged his system. What does he expect to do with it if it is stored? Put it in a museum?

- Doctor Flox must be a wiz kid in genetics even before Dr. McCoy. It takes him a few hours to come up with an answer to eradicating the viral transformation? Would it not have been more interesting to know that the virus will remain dormant instead of eradicated by the hours of intense effort? Disease in this timeline must be nonexistant!

- Wow the good Captain sure has alot of treasures he is collecting. I wonder if this will ever boomerang on him in a future episode. We now have a small invisible vehicle, time travel data and equipment locked in a cabin, enhansed sensors ala the star fairing race that took him near the sun, a virus that can mutate humanoids. What next?


reply to this

Re: Survival of the fittest? No DNAing it!
posted by Lurch_Kimded on October 2 2003, 12:57 am
- Wow the good Captain sure has alot of treasures he is collecting. ... a virus that can mutate humanoids. What next?
Hmmm.... can anyone else see a Biologial warfare getting used on the humanoid Xindi? That could certainly make for an interesting (if highly immoral) decision on Archer's part wither to use this virus as a weapon, or to show a more civilised and "Star Trek" way.

reply to this

Re: Survival of the fittest? No DNAing it!
posted by TechnoGirl on October 2 2003, 2:32 pm
<BLOCKQUOTE TYPE="cite">
Hmmm.... can anyone else see a Biologial warfare getting used on the humanoid Xindi?</BLOCKQUOTE>

Google up Checkov's Law regarding plays.

Of course the virus is going to be used.....booorrrring....

Last night I watched Smallville which I thought was great! I channel surfed between commercials and caught some "hot women on women action" between T'its and some other character as predicted by someone here last week.

Star Trek is dead.... and Bermen and Braga killed it.



reply to this



<< Alias Review: The Two  | Post a comment | Jake 2.0 Discussion - "Arms and the Girl" >>
 
Current Headlines
Fringe Discussion: "The Equation" (0)
Weekly Comics Discussion - November 19, 2008 (0)
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles: "Complications" (4)
Heroes Discussion: It's Coming (1)
Star Trek Trailer Now Online (5)
Comic Films (0)
LHC Rap (0)
Weekend Review - "Quantum of Solace" (8)

Other SF Sites
Sci-Fi Storm

<i>Robotech</i> feature gets new writers, rewrite
<i>Star Trek</i> trailers now live
The Phoenix Comicon Shows the Enterprise's Data Some Fun
<i>World War Z</i> gets direction from Marc Forster
One pickup, one axe, and one beer...
Image of new Enterprise
<i>Knight Rider</i> gets downsized, rebooted
Johnston to direct <i>First Avenger: Captain America</i>
John Williams/Star Wars a capella tribute
<i>Lost</i> 5th season to start January 21st
STARTREK.COM - Headlines

Next Remastered Episode: "Tomorrow Is Yesterday"
Keep the conversation going on StarTrek.com boards
Okuda Logo for New Lunar Lander Unveiled
"InAlienable" Premieres, "Of Gods & Men" Soon!
Jerry Goldsmith: A Personal Reminiscence
TNG20: It Was Twenty Years Ago Today (December 1987)
EDITOR'S PICK: Suzie Plakson - "Good Luck Charm" CD
Etchstar Customized iPod nano Giveaway
ASK KATE: Trekkies, Trekkers, Which Is It?
POLL: Which TNG "gift" would you like this holiday season?

Other Random Cool Sites
Ars Technica

Eulogy for a good friend: RIP, twisted pair telephone line
Google copyright deal moves forward
Co-op resurrected: Ars reviews Left 4 Dead
WiFi goes green: solar-powered outdoor nodes coming soon
Tennessee anti-P2P law to cost colleges over $13 million
US court orders keylogger CyberSpy to halt software sales
Judge slaps down Psystar's antitrust claims against Apple
HP previews strong fourth quarter
Who's top in tech policy? Our new "People to Watch" list
Kodak sues LG and Samsung over alleged patent violations
Crowdsourcing patent startup could use dose of own medicine
Hands on: Google lets you search with your voice on iPhone
Australian police warn that racing games breed bad drivers
Study: many young people want to do their banking over IM
Microsoft on the cloud: Sharepoint and Exchange go Online
A feature guide to current-generation gaming consoles
Sirius, XM subscribers revolt over merger-induced changes
Game on: NVIDIA, PS3 hardware in Top 500 Supercomputers list
Hands on: Zenbe's social, collaborative e-mail works well
Intel's 3.2GHz monster Nehalem roars onto the scene
[H]ardOCP News/Article Feed

G4saurus Defectus
Gigabyte EX58-Extreme Mobo Sneak Peek
CPG Files for Bankruptcy Protection
[H]ardware Round-Up II
Fashion Your Firefox
DivX Sues Yahoo Over Canceled Ad Deal
Gaming News
Sony Claims 14 Million PSN Users
New 'Halo'-esque Look for Korea's Troops
[H]ardware Round-Up
Spansion Sues Samsung Over Flash Patents
iPhone Numeric Keypad App
[H]ot Deal Of The Day
Identities Sold Online For Cheap
Velocity Micro First to Ship New Intel Core i7 Systems
AMD Analyst Day November 2008
Fallout 3 Gameplay Performance and Image Quality
Your Mail in Rebate May Be In Jeopardy
Intel Core i7 920 Overclocking and Power
OCZ 700W ModXStream Pro Power Supply
ASUS Rampage II Extreme
Galaxy GeForce GTX 260+ Overclocked Version
Intel Core i7 920 Overclocking and Heat
ASUS P6T Deluxe
Intel Core i7 and Gaming
Intel Core i7 Application Results
Intel Core i7 Synthetic Benchmarks
EVGA 790i SLI FTW Motherboard
FarCry 2 Gameplay Performance
Gigabyte GA-EP45T-Extreme
Slashdot

Fewer Than 1% Arrested From TSA's "Behavior Detection"
Psystar Antitrust Claim Against Apple Dismissed
Oldest Nuclear Family Found Murdered In Germany
The Importance of Procedural Content Generation In Games
Court Slams Door On Sale of Spyware
Should You Get Paid While Your Computer Boots?
Ted Stevens Loses Senate Re-Election Bid
Microsoft To Offer Free Anti-Virus Software
NASA Tests Deep-Space Network Modeled On the Internet
McColo Briefly Returns, Hands Off Botnet Control
Google To Host 10M Images From Life Magazine's Archive
The Neurological Basis of Con Games
Secure OS Gets Highest NSA Rating, Goes Commercial
The ISS Marks 10 Years In Space
New Generator Boosts Wind Turbine Efficiency 50%


Want our headlines on your site? You can snag our RSS file and go to town. (RDF/RSS parser sold separately.) All site content © and owned by its author - for the full skinny, read the legal disclaimers bit.