bureau42.com      

bureau42.com email
Check your mail, or get a free address

Add to Google

part of the everyone.net Entertainment Network

Dreamhost Web Hosting

Problems with the site? Comments? Questions? Let us know!

 
welcome to bureau42.com
 
Doctor Who: Army of Ghosts
posted July 5 2006, 1:54 am by Eldhrin

Category: Doctor Who Torchwood! Cybermen! Mickey Smith! A cliffhanger and a spoilerific opening narration! Yes folks, this episode has it all.

Read more... ( 18 comments already posted ) | ( 4571 bytes in body ) | ( Post a comment )


<< Shuttle Delayed till 4th of July  | Post a comment | New Doctor Who Companion Named >>

Cast and Crew

David Tennant as the Doctor
Billie Piper as Rose Tyler
Camille Coduri as Jackie Tyler
Noel Clarke as Mickey Smith
Adam Shaw as Morris
Derek Acorah played himself
Raji James as Doctor Singh
Nicholas Briggs was the voice of the Cybermen
Oliver Mellow as Matt
David Warwick as Police Commissioner
Rachel Webster as Eileen
Tracy-Ann Oberman as Yvonne Hartman
Alistair Appleton played himself
Barbara Windsor played herself
Rochelle Gadd as Sally
Hadley Fraser as Gareth

Written by Russell T. Davies

Directed by Graeme Harper

Originally aired on the 1st of July 2006 on BBC One in the United Kingdom.

Synopsis

Returning home for a visit, Rose and the Doctor are rather surprised when a ghost arrives in Jackie's kitchen. Tracking down the source of this manifestation leads them to the Torchwood Institute, an army of Cybermen... and something worse.

High Points

  • Rose taking action by herself again. Okay so it didn't work out, but it's good to see her trying.
  • 'Umm... my mum's still on board.'
  • How the Doctor persuades Yvonne not to run the machine on schedule.
  • The final scene raises the tension and the potential for death and destruction rather higher than I was expecting.

Low Points

  • Surely somebody noticed people suddenly wearing two earpieces when one sufficed before? Especially when those two earpieces have flashing lights on and make beeping noises.
  • The final scene is, in hindsight, just the sort of thing we should have expected from Russell T. Davies. There's some justification for it, but we'll have to wait until next week to see if it's been mishandled as badly as it could be.

The Scores

Investigating an anomaly you know nothing about makes it worse and plays right into the hands of your enemies. Not hugely original, but fortunately it doesn't feel like a tired retread of old ground. Four out of six.

Good effects. The ghosts looked exactly like they should given what the story explains them as, and I still really like the TARDIS de/materialisation they're using. The mysterious sphere looks good too; although one thinks perhaps it's painted on, and maybe it is, this seems entirely compatible with it being something that doesn't appear to exist by most measurements. Six out of six.

The story offers up copious amounts of peril, potential disaster and possibly an enormous body count, with momentous events promised. As it's the end of the series this is good stuff, as we have rather got used to a series ending with a bit of a spectacle. The biggest criticism I would have is that most of the Torchwood people are, as my sister puts it, exactly the same as everyone else we've seen. I might not go quite that far, but they're certainly not revealing themselves as new and interesting characters. Also as mentioned in the low points, the final scene could turn out to be what ruins it, but we won't know until next week. Five out of six.

The acting was good, particularly Oberman's portrayal of her character, who isn't the most interesting of people but does come across exactly as she needs to. Five out of six.

My emotional response was mixed in the final reckoning, as I'm still dubious about the events of the last minute or so. Before that, things were getting nicely tense and there's a definite knowledge that things are going to go horribly, horribly wrong. Perhaps if Rose hadn't said she was going to die right at the start of the episode in her narration, we'd get more emotional response out of things next week. Four out of six.

Much credit to the production team. The Cybermen have been improved, and now appear to be using three LEDs to talk with, as one would have hoped they would from the start. Torchwood looked much like it should, a cross between a high-tech office space and Q Branch in a James Bond film, with added alien technology. Six out of six.

Overall it's good, but there are some misgivings about where it's going. Still have to give it six out of six as those misgivings showed up in some of the other scores.

Army of Ghosts receives a grand total of thirty-six out of forty-two. Par for the course recently, and it's nice to see a consistent standard.



 Comments

Hmm..
posted by Chillum on July 5 2006, 3:38 am
Bit patchy this one. The ghosts were nicely done, and I liked the Eastenders scene. The Doctor's explanation of why the Ghost Shifts were a bad idea was really good too. Some of the stuff with the excellent Jackie made me smile.

Minor quibble: when Rose used the psychic paper to open the door, whose mind was it reading?

I agree the ending was the worst part of this episode; without saying too much, it just seemed like Russell T. etc. were taking the easy option, a bit lazy and predictable I thought.

Still looking forward to next week's finale, but not quite as much as I'd like to be.

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by y42 on July 5 2006, 6:04 am
Minor quibble: when Rose used the psychic paper to open the door, whose mind was it reading?

It wasn't reading, it was projecting what the computer controlling the card reader wanted to read, just like it projects whatever the people reading it want to read (if you're having a problem with psychic effects on computers, remember that the chinese characters for "computer" mean "electric brain", and that you're watching Docotr Who :)

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by Alexius on July 5 2006, 11:28 am
Minor quibble: when Rose used the psychic paper to open the door, whose mind was it reading?

It wasn't reading, it was projecting what the computer controlling the card reader wanted to read, just like it projects whatever the people reading it want to read (if you're having a problem with psychic effects on computers, remember that the chinese characters for "computer" mean "electric brain", and that you're watching Docotr Who :)


Or: The Paper Was Reading Rose's Mind, And Displaying What She Wanted It To Display, In This Case, An Access Card.

I Thought It Was What The Holder Wanted The Receiver To See. Which Is Why Captain Jack's Showed That He Worked Out To Rose. It Was What He Wanted, Now What She Wanted To See.

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by y42 on July 5 2006, 12:22 pm
Or: The Paper Was Reading Rose's Mind, And Displaying What She Wanted It To Display, In This Case, An Access Card.

I Thought It Was What The Holder Wanted The Receiver To See.

Can't be, the Doctor doesn't know what the people he shows it to will see. That was quite clear in the Queen Victoria VS Werewolf episode.
The Doctor often suggests what the paper says, and the reader will expect that, and therefore see it. But if he just flashes the paper, it's all up to the recipient to see what he needs to see.

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by Alexius on July 5 2006, 9:44 pm

Can't be, the Doctor doesn't know what the people he shows it to will see. That was quite clear in the Queen Victoria VS Werewolf episode.


I Took That As The Doctor Was Thinking Of How He Was Standing As Earth's Champion, And The Paper Added That, Again, Like How Captain Jack's Added The Detail That He Worked Out.

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by Chillum on July 5 2006, 4:13 pm
Or: The Paper Was Reading Rose's Mind, And Displaying What She Wanted It To Display, In This Case, An Access Card.

For that to work, wouldn't she need to know what a genuine access card looked like?

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by Chillum on July 5 2006, 4:10 pm
(if you're having a problem with psychic effects on computers, remember that the chinese characters for "computer" mean "electric brain", and that you're watching Docotr Who :)

Yeah, that's the problem I'm having :) nice shot at an explanation there.. but.. why not just have her find an access card in the lab coat or something? Even I couldn't quibble about that!

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by y42 on July 5 2006, 6:30 pm
(if you're having a problem with psychic effects on computers, remember that the chinese characters for "computer" mean "electric brain", and that you're watching Docotr Who :)

Yeah, that's the problem I'm having :) nice shot at an explanation there.. but.. why not just have her find an access card in the lab coat or something? Even I couldn't quibble about that!

It's bad enough they have lab coats her size lying around, if there were an acess card with the right authorisation in it, I'd have a fit :-P

The lesson is: Slightly psychic paper works on non-sentient thinking machines. Now we know.

reply to this

Re: Hmm..
posted by babasyzygy on July 5 2006, 11:55 pm
The lesson is: Slightly psychic paper works on non-sentient thinking machines. Now we know.

Alternatively, Rose lucked out and Torchwood is using sentient computers for access control, or has a wetware brain wired into the network, or who knows what? This is Torchwood, they potentially have access to anything alien predating the 21st century.

"Oh yes, we use Silurian biotech for all our security - we were having too many problems getting locked in whenever the Terileptil gun generated an EMP."

reply to this

Rose
posted by codejnki on July 5 2006, 4:30 am
I think the revelation in the voice over that Rose dies means she will die early in the episode, causing just the right amount of rage in The Doctor to save the day.

reply to this

PULL THE F%$#&*@ TRIGGER!
posted by Cerberus7 on July 5 2006, 6:55 am
There seem to be a lot of somewhat awkward and unnecessary pauses in this show. I was just about ready to jump up and yell "Mickey! Pull the F%$#&*@ trigger already!" I will now make it my mission in life to do so every time a similar incident occurs. Now I have to go and watch all the other episodes again to begin my catalogue.

reply to this

Re: PULL THE F%$#&*@ TRIGGER!
posted by Eldhrin on July 5 2006, 8:15 am
There seem to be a lot of somewhat awkward and unnecessary pauses in this show. I was just about ready to jump up and yell "Mickey! Pull the F%$#&*@ trigger already!" I will now make it my mission in life to do so every time a similar incident occurs. Now I have to go and watch all the other episodes again to begin my catalogue.

Good move, although if it's a weapon that works on the Cybermen, perhaps based on Cybertechnology, will it work on Daleks? We've already seen that the Daleks in this series are a heck of a lot tougher than the Cybermen we've seen.

Still, criticising Mickey has been one of my favourite things to do, and the moment I realised where the Cybermen were coming from I started praying for Mickey not to show up.

Alas, I was disappointed.

reply to this

Re: PULL THE F%$#&*@ TRIGGER!
posted by Alexius on July 5 2006, 11:32 am
Good move, although if it's a weapon that works on the Cybermen, perhaps based on Cybertechnology, will it work on Daleks? We've already seen that the Daleks in this series are a heck of a lot tougher than the Cybermen we've seen.

Mickey's Never Seen A Dalek Before. Rose Knows What They Are, But Not Mickey.

reply to this

Genre references ...
posted by joe__gee on July 5 2006, 1:45 pm
Is that a Vipyr the TARDIS is in front of when Rose goes out to investigate Canary Wharf/Torchwood? And is there any chance that sarcophagus might be from "Pyramids of Mars"? The "Jaffa sun glider" (death glider?) from Stargate SG-1. :) Excellent. :)

-Joe

reply to this

Re: Genre references ...
posted by fsphil on July 7 2006, 2:21 pm
Is that a Vipyr the TARDIS is in front of when Rose goes out to investigate Canary Wharf/Torchwood?


Well spotted! It looks like the flattened front of a Viper, but the wing (where the lab coat was) was too big -- if that was even a part of it. Hard to tell. I was able to take a few screen grabs to have a closer look:

http://www.firestorm.cx/files/

(The images are called army_of_ghosts-*.jpeg)

reply to this

Re: Genre references ...
posted by y42 on July 8 2006, 8:26 am
It looks like the flattened front of a Viper, but the wing (where the lab coat was) was too big -- if that was even a part of it. Hard to tell.

Good job on the screenshots.

Yah, that wing is part of the craft, and is too big to be a Galactica prop. Generic space fighter plane I'm affraid.

reply to this

Wow.
posted by joe__gee on July 8 2006, 7:22 pm
I won't spoil it for anyone who hasn't yet watched their dvr, or grabbed the episode by Bittorrent, other than to say that the payoff from this two-parter is absolutely extraordinary. This ep might have been mediocre. The next, at least for me, was anything but.

PLEASE HURRY UP WITH THE NEXT REVIEW ELDHRIN. :)

-Joe

reply to this

Re: Wow.
posted by hans on July 10 2006, 9:17 am
I won't spoil it for anyone who hasn't yet watched their dvr, or grabbed the episode by Bittorrent, other than to say that the payoff from this two-parter is absolutely extraordinary. This ep might have been mediocre. The next, at least for me, was anything but.


I thought the first half was better than the second half, overall, but there's some very good moments in the second half and it wraps things up nicely and still leaves you with something to look forward to in the Christmas episode (I hate cliffhangers).

reply to this



<< Shuttle Delayed till 4th of July  | Post a comment | New Doctor Who Companion Named >>
 
Current Headlines
Millar and Gough now to write "Robotech" Movie (2)
Fringe Discussion: "The Equation" (2)
Weekly Comics Discussion - November 19, 2008 (0)
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles: "Complications" (6)
Heroes Discussion: It's Coming (2)
Star Trek Trailer Now Online (6)
Comic Films (0)
LHC Rap (0)

Other SF Sites
Sci-Fi Storm

"The Genesis of Doctor Who" notes available at the BBC
<i>Robotech</i> feature gets new writers, rewrite
<i>Star Trek</i> trailers now live
The Phoenix Comicon Shows the Enterprise's Data Some Fun
<i>World War Z</i> gets direction from Marc Forster
One pickup, one axe, and one beer...
Image of new Enterprise
<i>Knight Rider</i> gets downsized, rebooted
Johnston to direct <i>First Avenger: Captain America</i>
John Williams/Star Wars a capella tribute
STARTREK.COM - Headlines

Next Remastered Episode: "Tomorrow Is Yesterday"
Keep the conversation going on StarTrek.com boards
Okuda Logo for New Lunar Lander Unveiled
"InAlienable" Premieres, "Of Gods & Men" Soon!
Jerry Goldsmith: A Personal Reminiscence
TNG20: It Was Twenty Years Ago Today (December 1987)
EDITOR'S PICK: Suzie Plakson - "Good Luck Charm" CD
Etchstar Customized iPod nano Giveaway
ASK KATE: Trekkies, Trekkers, Which Is It?
POLL: Which TNG "gift" would you like this holiday season?

Other Random Cool Sites
Ars Technica

Report: Online shoppers cutting back this holiday season
Report: Want to be a green gamer? Turn off your console
McColo reconnect highlights network security gap
Resurrecting the mammoth? New research raises the prospect
Faster than the speed of dark: annihilations above Antarctica
Grow your own: tissue engineering saves patient's lung
Antipiracy group pushes 10 years jail time for UK infringers
EU launches public consultation on Internet security
FCC Commissioner calls for Portable People Meter probe
Amazon CloudFront turns S3 into content distribution network
Scientists see political attacks as badge of pride
Eulogy for a good friend: RIP, twisted pair telephone line
Google copyright deal moves forward
Co-op resurrected: Ars reviews Left 4 Dead
WiFi goes green: solar-powered outdoor nodes coming soon
Tennessee anti-P2P law to cost colleges over $13 million
US court orders keylogger CyberSpy to halt software sales
Judge slaps down Psystar's antitrust claims against Apple
HP previews strong fourth quarter
Who's top in tech policy? Our new "People to Watch" list
[H]ardOCP News/Article Feed

BFG Technologies Offers Rebate Remedy
Five Tech Predictions From 1968 That Came True
Window 7 Media Center On Video
Ballmer Dismisses Yahoo Buyout But Open On Search
Koolance CPU-350 Sneak Peek
Gaming News
AMD Analyst Day November 2008
[H]ardware Round-Up
Blu-ray Burners To Go Mainstream In PCs By 2011
[H]ard|OCP [H]otDeals
Exciting Features For Ubuntu 9.04
NASA Tests "Deep Space Internet"
VIA Launches VIPRO Touch-Screen Panel PC
Mark Cuban Responds to SEC Charges
Tennessee Governor Signs Campus Downloading Bill Into Law
AMD Analyst Day November 2008
Fallout 3 Gameplay Performance and Image Quality
Your Mail in Rebate May Be In Jeopardy
Intel Core i7 920 Overclocking and Power
OCZ 700W ModXStream Pro Power Supply
ASUS Rampage II Extreme
Galaxy GeForce GTX 260+ Overclocked Version
Intel Core i7 920 Overclocking and Heat
ASUS P6T Deluxe
Intel Core i7 and Gaming
Intel Core i7 Application Results
Intel Core i7 Synthetic Benchmarks
EVGA 790i SLI FTW Motherboard
FarCry 2 Gameplay Performance
Gigabyte GA-EP45T-Extreme
Slashdot

Apple's New MacBooks Have Built-In Copy Protection
Windows Breaks Into Supercomputer Top10
Interviewing Experienced IT People?
Monty Python Banks On the Long Tail Via YouTube
FCC Publishes "White Spaces" Rules
NRDC Rates Energy Efficiency of Video Game Consoles
London's Oystercard Gets New Contract, But Same Suppliers
Wolfram Research Releases Mathematica 7
Lunar Oxygen and Water Production Tech Tested
Microsoft Feared Mac Vs. Vista In '05
American Nerd
Astronaut Loses Tools While Performing an EVA
Ray Kurzweil Wonders, Can Machines Ever Have Souls?
Fewer Than 1% Arrested From TSA's "Behavior Detection"
Psystar Antitrust Claim Against Apple Dismissed


Want our headlines on your site? You can snag our RSS file and go to town. (RDF/RSS parser sold separately.) All site content © and owned by its author - for the full skinny, read the legal disclaimers bit.