bureau42.com      

bureau42.com email
Check your mail, or get a free address

Add to Google

part of the everyone.net Entertainment Network

Dreamhost Web Hosting

Problems with the site? Comments? Questions? Let us know!

 
welcome to bureau42.com
 
Saturday Movie Review - "Stargate: Director's Cut"
posted July 8 2006, 8:06 am by fiziko

Category: Movies Note that there will be a change of plans for the forthcoming Saturday reviews. The next three weeks will be reviews of the three Terminator movies. A new schedule will be posted within the next week.

Read more... ( 7 comments already posted ) | ( 4617 bytes in body ) | ( Post a comment )


<< Strangers in Paradise: Heart in Hand  | Post a comment | Weekly DVD Picks - July 11, 2006 >>

Cast, Crew, and Other Info

James Spader as Daniel Jackson.
Kurt Russel as Jack O'Neil
Alexis Cruz as Skaara
Jaye Davidson as Ra
Mili Avital as Sha'uri
Erick Avari as Kasuf
French Stewart as Ferretti
John Diehl as Lieutenan Kawalsky

Written by Dean Devlin and Roland Emmerich
Directed by Roland Emmerich

Complete information is available from the IMDB.

Buy from: Amazon.com or Amazon.ca. That's pretty darn cheap, too.

Past movie reviews can be found here.

Premise

In 1928, technology beyond anything we'd be able to create today was found buried in Egypt. In 1994, the genius of Daniel Jackson allows the military to finally turn the thing on and travel to another world.

High Point

"I have an idea."

Low Point

Constellations are terrible reference points. They should have at least mentioned something about how the reference must be a particular star within the constellation, but they don't know which one. This still has a problem, though, in that most of the stars in the constellations found that long ago look bright because they're really, really close, and there's no way they could be sent to "the other end of the known galaxy" using them as guides.

The Scores

This is Devlin and Emmerich's best and most original collaboration. It has a blend of the heady sci-fi Emmerich worked on with Moon 44 (where the two met) with just enough of the action and mass audience appeal that Devlin brought to the team to make it commercially viable. (It was the increasing amount of this contribution that turns me off their later collaborations.) There are few areas where the exploration of ancient Egypt will turn into a sci-fi action film, too. I give it 5 out of 6.

The effects work fairly well for the budget. There are times when the sand beneath the pyramid is clearly CGI, and other times when the city is clearly a model, but most of the effects work well. I give it 4 out of 6.

The story is well done. In this, the Director's Cut, we get a few scenes about the other item found at the dig site (that didn't make a huge contribution to the movie as a whole), but the biggest difference when compared to the theatrical edition is that the other soldiers (and Ferretti in particular) play larger roles, providing some of the information provided by Jackson and/or O'Neil in the theatrical release. It makes this feel more like a team effort and less like a pair of effective individuals surrounded by incompetants. The main story is interesting as well, with some decent justification for the lack of long-term development of a culture over 1000 years. I also like the fact that the cause of death of O'Neil's son is clear, but never stated aloud. It shows a lot of respect for the audience, and makes us realize that we may have misjudged O'Neil's intentions the first time we saw him. I give it 5 out of 6.

The acting was well done. Spader and Russell are certainly recognizable, but neither was a major star when this came out. The casting was chosen based on ability, which is also why every major Israeli actor and actress found a spot here somewhere. I give it 5 out of 6.

The emotional response is fairly strong. I wasn't on the edge of my seat, but I was entertained, even on repeated viewings. I give it 4 out of 6.

The production was well done. David Arnold's score was great, particularly for a relative newcomer. The lighting didn't have a lot of variation, and the scenes with the second relic should have stayed cut, but it's a decent little movie by some (then) little known creators. I give it 4 out of 6.

Overall, it's a decently entertaining movie, worth checking out, particularly as a lead-in to the series. I give it 4 out of 6.

In total, the director's cut of Stargate receives 31 out of 42.



 Comments

I wonder
posted by y42 on July 8 2006, 8:23 am
When I saw this, I felt like 60 pages of the script had been ripped out.
A whole people in subjugation of their incarnate, very present gods rebell on the word of some strangers, and they just happen to know how to use automatic weapons, which they learned to operate despite being uneducated slaves and without injuring themselves... I didn't buy it.

I wonder if the director's cut is more believable... it would have to be, to get such a high score...

reply to this

Not a major star?
posted by 3vi1 on July 8 2006, 2:32 pm
>> Spader and Russell are certainly recognizable, but neither was a major star when this came out

Leading roles in Big Trouble in Little China, The Thing, Escape From New York, Tango and Cash, Captain Ron, etc. and appearances in at least 60 TV shows and movies in the 30 years prior to Stargate, and you say Kurt Russell wasn't a major star when this was released?

reply to this

Re: Not a major star?
posted by joe__gee on July 8 2006, 4:58 pm

Leading roles in Big Trouble in Little China, The Thing, Escape From New York, Tango and Cash, Captain Ron, etc. and appearances in at least 60 TV shows and movies in the 30 years prior to Stargate, and you say Kurt Russell wasn't a major star when this was released?


My thoughts too. Not to nit-pick the reviewer's work, but ... :)

As you point out, Russell did his time as a TV star, then he had plenty of work as a star in successful action and dramatic films (in addition to the movies already mentioned, include "Backdraft", "Silkwood", and "Tombstone"), and his turn in comedies ("Overboard", probably his most successful.)

And Spader was one of the "brat pack" of the 80's, culminating with "Sex Lies & Videotape", plus he played the nerdy, evil department store manager in "Mannequin", he was in "Less Than Zero", "Pretty in Pink" ... "Diner." In 1994, when he was cast in Stargate he had significant cachet as a film star from his work in the 80's.

They were both widely recognized names on the movie poster, although from this movie both actors certainly received boosts in their careers at a time when their names were not as widely seen as they had been in previous years. In an industry where visibility = star power, both Spader and Russell had previously seen wider exposure. Perhaps this is what the reviewer meant to say. :)

-Joe

reply to this

Re: Not a major star?
posted by fiziko on July 9 2006, 5:45 am
I worked in a theater when this came out. Everyone knew Kurt Russell's name, but people weren't seeing his movies just because he was in them, like they were doing with Tom Hanks at the time. Over half of the audience had no idea who Spader was and what else he'd been in until I told them. That's what I meant.

reply to this

Re: Not a major star?
posted by Timeshredder on July 9 2006, 5:56 am
It's worth mentioning that Russell's early crossover from television had him playing nerd hero "Dexter Reilly" in three Disney films.


reply to this

spoil me
posted by octa on July 9 2006, 6:50 am
Can someone spoil it for me and tell me what the 2nd relic was in the director's cut?

reply to this

Re: spoil me
posted by amphigory on July 11 2006, 7:18 pm
Can someone spoil it for me and tell me what the 2nd relic was in the director's cut?


If I remember correctly:
They uncover a fossil showing one of Ra's soldiers

reply to this



<< Strangers in Paradise: Heart in Hand  | Post a comment | Weekly DVD Picks - July 11, 2006 >>
 
Current Headlines
Doctor Who Discussion: Turn Left, The Missing Earth, and Journey's End (1)
Weekly Digital Disc Picks - July 8, 2008 (0)
Metropolis Found (2)
Movie Discussion: Hancock (5)
Weekly Comics Discussion - July 2, 2008 (0)
Don S. Davis 1942-2008 (4)
Hugo Awards: Short Fiction (1)
Secret Invasion Review - "Mighty Avengers #15" (0)

Other SF Sites
Sci-Fi Storm

<i>X-Files Revelations</i> DVD release this Tuesday
Just in time for next year's Twilight Zone Marathon
<i>Stargate Atlantis: Season 4</i> DVD review
Bits o'Stargate news
Star Wars Fan Movie Challenge voting!
<i>Stargate SG-1</i> actor Don S. Davis passed away
Ain't It Cool reports on some early <i>Star Trek</i> footage
Babylon 5 fans donate G'Kar special effects mask to museum
<i>John Carter of Mars</i> may be animated
Store updates
STARTREK.COM - Headlines

Next Remastered Episode: "Tomorrow Is Yesterday"
Keep the conversation going on StarTrek.com boards
Okuda Logo for New Lunar Lander Unveiled
"InAlienable" Premieres, "Of Gods & Men" Soon!
Jerry Goldsmith: A Personal Reminiscence
TNG20: It Was Twenty Years Ago Today (December 1987)
EDITOR'S PICK: Suzie Plakson - "Good Luck Charm" CD
Etchstar Customized iPod nano Giveaway
ASK KATE: Trekkies, Trekkers, Which Is It?
POLL: Which TNG "gift" would you like this holiday season?

Other Random Cool Sites
Ars Technica

Five ways to keep your PC cool on a hot summer day
Bandwidth caps could lead to ISPs benefiting from piracy
Yankee Hotel Net Neutrality? Indie rockers back an open 'Net
Judge: FISA trumps state secrets, binds executive branch
No Google source code for Viacom, just 12TB of YouTube data
Report: US broadband market edging towards saturation
Virgin, BPI at odds as first infringement letters go out
EMI joins Viacom in trying to drain the UGC safe harbor
OpenMoko FreeRunner Linux phone to launch on July 4
Civil liberties groups sue for info on cell phone lojacking
Groups: FCC indecency process stifles creative expression
Hands on: Filtrbox tries to filter out information overload
First look: Mozilla Weave 0.2 puts Firefox in the cloud
Poll: US taxpayers want more funding for scientific research
AMD narrows market share gap with Intel, revenue gap grows
Mobile group to establish security standards for mobile web
Mozilla sets Guinness World Record with Firefox 3 launch
Senators to FCC: Sirius/XM's proposal still needs work
Australia shows US how a real broadband strategy works
Microhoo redux? Something's up, but no one quite knows what
[H]ardOCP News/Article Feed

Microsoft Equipt: A Look Into the Future?
Readius Almost Ready for Release
NVIDIA Cuts Prices on High End Cards
Why Microsoft Will Win Yahoo
[H] Gaming News
Firefox 3 Sends Mozilla Market Share Above 19%
Finding the Optimal Laptop Configuration
[H]ardware Roundup: Post-Fireworks Edition
Intel and AMD Show Growth in Q1
Dell Website Gets Redesign
iPhone 3G Line Forming One Week Early in NYC
Go Green With Weather-Sensing Irrigation Gadget
Adobe Releases PDF Copyright to ISO
Microsoft Update to Get Update
Website Allows Users to Prepay for Gas, Lock in Price
Sigma Shark SP-635 Power Supply
BFGTech GeForce 9800 GTX H2OC WC Edition
Hiper Type-M 580w Power Supply
AMD Radeon HD 4800 Series
BFG Tech GeForce GTX 280 OC & GTX 260
NVIDIA Dictates Advertised Video Card Pricing
MSI P45 Platinum
BFG LS Series Power Supplies
Age of Conan Gameplay Performance and IQ
ASUS P5Q3 Deluxe
VIA Nano Processor White Paper
Thermaltake Purepower RX 600W
VIA Launches VIA Nano Processor Family
ASUS P5N-T Deluxe
BFGTech GeForce 9800 GTX OCX
Slashdot

LegalTorrents Offers CC Works Via BitTorrent
Keeping an Eye Out When Sites Go Down
550 Metric Tons of Uranium Removed From Iraq
Congress Tries To Strip Power From Anti-Wiretap Judge
The Internationalization of Malware
Scaling Large Projects With Erlang
US Justice Dept. Sued For Cellular Tracking Information
Bletchley Park Faces Financial Rescue
AVG Backs Down From Flooding the Internet
Your Computer As Your Singing Coach
New Pictures of White Knight Two and SpaceshipTwo
KDE 4.1 Beta 2 – Two Steps Forward, One Step Back?
Digitizing Old Magazines?
Finding Fault With Google's Privacy Policy
In Japan, a 900 Gigabyte Upload Cap, Downloads Uncapped


Want our headlines on your site? You can snag our RSS file and go to town. (RDF/RSS parser sold separately.) All site content © and owned by its author - for the full skinny, read the legal disclaimers bit.