bureau42.com      

bureau42.com email
Check your mail, or get a free address

Add to Google

part of the everyone.net Entertainment Network

Dreamhost Web Hosting

Problems with the site? Comments? Questions? Let us know!

 
welcome to bureau42.com
 
Battlestar Galactica Review: Escape Velocity
posted April 27 2008, 12:18 pm by Eldhrin

Category: Battlestar Galactica Fortunately everything worked in good time this week.

Read more... ( 15 comments already posted ) | ( 3278 bytes in body ) | ( Post a comment )


<< Weekly Digital Disc Discussion - April 29, 2008  | Post a comment | Weekend Review - "Death Note, Vol. 1" >>

Cast

James Callis as Dr. Gaius Baltar
Edward James Olmos as Admiral Adama
Mary McDonnell as Laura Roslin
Jamie Bamber as Lee "Apollo" Adama
Michael Hogan as Col. Tigh
Tricia Helfer as Number 6
Grace Park as Sharon "Athena" Agathon/Boomer
Tahmoh Penikett as Helo
Aaron Douglas as Galen Tyrol
Kandyse McClure as Anastasia "Dee" Dualla
Alessandro Juliani as Felix Gaeta
Rekha Sharma as Tory Foster
Michael Trucco as Samuel T. Anders

Synopsis

Tigh has increasing difficulty with his status as a Cylon, while Tyrol has to deal with his grief and Baltar's cult suffers increasingly violent religious persecution.

High Points

  • "We have thirty thousand people left and they're not happy unless they're kicking each other's teeth in!"
  • Tigh's meetings with Six
  • Tyrol and Adama in the bar

Low Points

I really don't think there are any.

The Scores

Originality: The parallels with the modern and historic worlds are increasingly obvious. The story's still fantastic, but the originality suffers when you see bits of human history being played out in this little fleet of spaceships (albeit with some... modifications). Four out of six.

Effects: The Raptor crash wasn't as good as most of the exploding ship effects we've seen. Unfortunate. Four out of six.

Story: There's an awful lot going on now, and it gives a wonderfully pacey episode with significant events almost continuously throughout it. The only problem with this is that there's not time to visit all the threads in each episode, but at least we do get a suitably-sized piece of each one each time to make sure things are progressing. Six out of six.

Acting: James Callis has a lovely 'I've-been-hit-in-the-head' look, and a great way of giving sermons. Six out of six.

Production: There is some gorgeous incidental music in this episode. Bear McCreary is a genius. Roslin is also looking subtly but increasingly ill, and that's very well done. Six out of six.

Emotional response: It's not quite up there with the end of last week, but it holds the emotions up and there's a lot to care about. Actually it's probably a good thing it's not quite up with last week, I'm not sure I could handle that every episode. Five out of six.

Overall: Another excellent episode. Six out of six.

Escape Velocity receives thirty-seven out of forty-two. More please!



 Comments

Almost too much going on
posted by Dark Nexus on April 27 2008, 1:06 pm
I almost felt that there was too much going on, and that there was almost no progress because of that.

Sure, there was a little progress in all of the plotlines that were in the episode, but it was scattered among them all and it ended up just feeling like baby steps with no overall progress.

reply to this

Re: Almost too much going on
posted by Alexius on April 28 2008, 6:14 am
I almost felt that there was too much going on, and that there was almost no progress because of that.

Sure, there was a little progress in all of the plotlines that were in the episode, but it was scattered among them all and it ended up just feeling like baby steps with no overall progress.


I concur! It's a lot of build up, we're obviously going somewhere, but isn't it time to be at the top of that first roller coaster hill already?

reply to this

Re: Almost too much going on
posted by Trekkie on April 28 2008, 6:44 am
I almost felt that there was too much going on, and that there was almost no progress because of that.

Sure, there was a little progress in all of the plotlines that were in the episode, but it was scattered among them all and it ended up just feeling like baby steps with no overall progress.


I concur! It's a lot of build up, we're obviously going somewhere, but isn't it time to be at the top of that first roller coaster hill already?


yay it wasn't just me then. I always worry my expectations are too high but this episode seemed rushed to progress multiple plot lines it was rather hard to keep up. Granted by this time of the night I've had a few extra drinks and getting a little hazy some times but this time I was sober and was really felt like I was breathless by the end of the episode.

reply to this

Baltar's Six
posted by lost on April 28 2008, 10:10 am
Was it just me or did it seem like Baltar's Six was more than just a halucination outside the temple when he was being beat up by the guards outside the temple. When Six picked him up, it looked like someone was holding him up from behind. When they showed it from the perspective of everyone else, it still looked like he was being held up, but this time by an invisible entity.

reply to this

Re: Baltar's Six
posted by octa on April 28 2008, 10:56 am
Yeah, it reminded me of that scene in Fight Club. It's not necessarily conclusive evidence there's a supernatural entity controlling him. Would be super cool if it did turn out to be that :)

I'm in the same boat of "too much plot lines, not enough progress." A lot and a little happened (does that make sense?). At the end of it, myself and the girlfriend both said "where the hell is this going?" at the same time. Was a funny moment.

I hope they can pull this off.

reply to this

Re: Baltar's Six
posted by valen1260 on April 29 2008, 6:09 am
Was it just me or did it seem like Baltar's Six was more than just a halucination...
I noticed that as well. Also, that Six gave Tori an interesting look at the very end of the episode. Was it jealousy, "You're one of the Five!", or something else?

reply to this

Re: Baltar's Six
posted by J_W_W on April 30 2008, 4:32 pm
Was it just me or did it seem like Baltar's Six was more than just a halucination...
I noticed that as well. Also, that Six gave Tori an interesting look at the very end of the episode. Was it jealousy, "You're one of the Five!", or something else?


It really did seem like they were standing there together, and not actually figment and real person, err cylon. That was a very well done and subtle shot.

reply to this

Re: Baltar's Six
posted by joe__gee on April 29 2008, 10:45 am
Was it just me or did it seem like Baltar's Six was more than just a halucination outside the temple when he was being beat up by the guards outside the temple. When Six picked him up, it looked like someone was holding him up from behind. When they showed it from the perspective of everyone else, it still looked like he was being held up, but this time by an invisible entity.

I'm thinking Baltar's head-Six is more than just a hallucination, as is Caprica Six's head-Baltar. We now know they can move between the flesh/skinjob Baltar and Six. I am wondering if the two can manifest in one person/cylon at the same time? I'm also wondering if they can act as messengers?

I enjoyed this very busy episode.

As for Chief, he has proven to himself that he does have other capabilities -- he pulled a 24 hour shift and didn't need sleep. He did what he did so he would be removed from a position of responsibility on Galactica's flight deck. He believes Cylon programming can override free will. He doesn't want to be used to sabotage the fleet's defenses.

-Joe

reply to this

Re: Baltar's Six
posted by J_W_W on April 30 2008, 4:39 pm
Was it just me or did it seem like Baltar's Six was more than just a halucination outside the temple when he was being beat up by the guards outside the temple. When Six picked him up, it looked like someone was holding him up from behind. When they showed it from the perspective of everyone else, it still looked like he was being held up, but this time by an invisible entity.

I'm thinking Baltar's head-Six is more than just a hallucination, as is Caprica Six's head-Baltar. We now know they can move between the flesh/skinjob Baltar and Six. I am wondering if the two can manifest in one person/cylon at the same time? I'm also wondering if they can act as messengers?

I enjoyed this very busy episode.

As for Chief, he has proven to himself that he does have other capabilities -- he pulled a 24 hour shift and didn't need sleep. He did what he did so he would be removed from a position of responsibility on Galactica's flight deck. He believes Cylon programming can override free will. He doesn't want to be used to sabotage the fleet's defenses.

-Joe

As much as I loved Adama's response to the Chief's meltdown.
He's now just the latest of the four to cease to be a person AND for me cease to be a meaningful character on the show. Everything hes done is meaningless. Tori and the Chief are now plot devices to move along the story. Not to say that's bad, but thats what they are now. Anders character isn't as deep as the chief and I predict his cylon meltdown to happen in the next episode and to be a key factor in stopping Starbuck from finding Earth. Tigh stands as the best character of the four left and really the only one who I think has a chance to stay human. Six's games with him this episode are really interesting and I think she's aiming at making him feel more human and not more cylon. I'm certain the way she was acting that she knows hes one of the five. If Tigh ends up melting down and betraying Adama, I'll be really dissapointed.

reply to this

Re: Baltar's Six
posted by joe__gee on April 30 2008, 7:47 pm

He's now just the latest of the four to cease to be a person AND for me cease to be a meaningful character on the show. Everything hes done is meaningless. Tori and the Chief are now plot devices to move along the story. Not to say that's bad, but thats what they are now. Anders character isn't as deep as the chief and I predict his cylon meltdown to happen in the next episode and to be a key factor in stopping Starbuck from finding Earth. Tigh stands as the best character of the four left and really the only one who I think has a chance to stay human. Six's games with him this episode are really interesting and I think she's aiming at making him feel more human and not more cylon. I'm certain the way she was acting that she knows hes one of the five. If Tigh ends up melting down and betraying Adama, I'll be really dissapointed.

I've been thinking about this all week. For me, when I review their stories I wonder what else these four might have done, or where they might have been. When I see how these four have found their ways into positions of power I wonder how they fit into the overall plan.

Who wrote the "there are twelve models" note that Adama found in his quarters? Who wrote "cylon" in Boomer's locker? Why did these four end up where they are? Someone among the "final five" may be an enemy, but someone is also a friend.

I don't see any of them except Tori turning against their previous lives or natures. I just see this as another revelation about their characters. I don't see what we know or have learned about any of these characters as meaningless unless they completely betray their nature. Back to Tori, we never knew that much about her other than she was Billy's replacement.

In the context of the show, the "final five" will answer the question of Cylon self will. Can any of them ever really be trusted? Can any of them ever really break free of their programming? Can any of them ever be more than they were engineered to be?

I think the show has always been about the Cylons. If they can truly overcome their nature, humanity survives. If they can't, it sucks to be a Colonist.

-Joe

reply to this

A couple of things
posted by aarku on April 28 2008, 7:53 pm
I was disappointed that they didn't investigate Cally's death at all. It stands out as a plot hole in my mind. Baltar's propping up by Six was very interesting. Rewatching it, it looks beyond what someone could act out without some sort of rig propping up a heck of a lot of his weight. And it was a bit weird seeing Admiral pips on Tigh's collar. I'll chalk it up to a wardrobe mishap. It was entertaining enough of an episode, but I kind of think there still is too much noise and character 180s to the point of I doubt the writers have some grand scheme, it's more trying to make each episode work together and hope it all connects enough at the end. I must say I used this a lot in my DnD campaigns, and it does a good job at keeping your audience/players interested until they figure out what you're doing. :p

reply to this

Religious overtones
posted by Kiersten on April 29 2008, 8:53 am
Is anyone else wondering where all the religious overtones are going to lead? Is it going to be another Robert Jordan where the show gets so thick with the battle of the beliefs that there is no other story left to tell?

Is this bothering anyone else out there or am I alone in this particular aspect of the Galactica universe.. ;)

I mean, I like the gods vs the one true god and such, but, to me, they are dwelling on it rather than tastefully hinting towards it.

I sure hope the future ones are better... there are ways to tell a story with religious aspects without shoving it down viewers throats.

jmo

K



reply to this

Re: Religious overtones
posted by valen1260 on April 29 2008, 9:38 am
I like the gods vs the one true god and such, but, to me, they are dwelling on it rather than tastefully hinting towards it.
Agreed. Plus, Xena already did that, and I can't help drawing comparisons. ;)

reply to this

Re: Religious overtones
posted by Timeshredder on April 29 2008, 11:47 am
I like the gods vs the one true god and such, but, to me, they are dwelling on it rather than tastefully hinting towards it.
Agreed. Plus, Xena already did that, and I can't help drawing comparisons. ;)



They're drawing upon the same historical events, of course. The Battlestar galaxy not only has the Classical pantheon and a Judeo-Christianesque God, this ep also mentions a Mithras cult.

reply to this

Re: Religious overtones
posted by joe__gee on April 30 2008, 11:32 am

They're drawing upon the same historical events, of course. The Battlestar galaxy not only has the Classical pantheon and a Judeo-Christianesque God, this ep also mentions a Mithras cult.

Interesting reading about the Mithras cult:

"This remarkable explanation of the tauroctony is based on two facts. First, every figure found in the standard tauroctony has a parallel among a group of constellations located along a continuous band in the sky: the bull is paralleled by Taurus, the dog by Canis Minor, the snake by Hydra, the raven by Corvus, and the scorpion by Scorpio. Second, Mithraic iconography in general is pervaded by explicit astronomical imagery: the zodiac, planets, sun, moon, and stars are often portrayed in Mithraic art; in addition, numerous ancient authors speak about astronomical subjects in connection with Mithraism. In the writings of the Neoplatonic philosopher Porphyry, for example, we find recorded a tradition that the cave which is depicted in the tauroctony and which the underground Mithraic temples were designed to imitate was intended to be 'an image of the cosmos.'"

From http://www.mystae.com/restricted/streams/gnosis/mithra.html .

In the BSG universe, a reverse map from Earth to Kobol or the Colonies?

-Joe

reply to this



<< Weekly Digital Disc Discussion - April 29, 2008  | Post a comment | Weekend Review - "Death Note, Vol. 1" >>
 
Current Headlines
People's Choice Awards Results (1)
Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season Eight Review - Issue 21 (0)
Secret Invasion / War of Kings Review - "Secret Invasion: War of Kings" (0)
Novel Review: The Stars My Destination (5)
Weekly Comics Discussion - January 7, 2008 (0)
Matt Smith IS The Doctor (9)
Weekly Digital Disc Picks - January 6, 2008 (0)
Weekend Review - "Dr. Horrible's Sing-A-Long Blog" (6)

Other SF Sites
Sci-Fi Storm

Peek at new <i>Star Trek</i> tech
<i>Tron</i> gets young lead actor
SCI FI Wire gets redesign
The new Doctor is...Matt Smith
New Doctor Who actor chosen -announced Saturday
Terry Farrell (of DS9) returns to the stage
<i>Terminator</i> joins the National Film Registry
Fox has rights to <i>Watchman</i>, according to judge
Disney says bon voyage to <i>Narnia: Treader</i>
<i>Babylon 5</i> music videos available online for the first time
STARTREK.COM - Headlines

Next Remastered Episode: "Tomorrow Is Yesterday"
Keep the conversation going on StarTrek.com boards
Okuda Logo for New Lunar Lander Unveiled
"InAlienable" Premieres, "Of Gods & Men" Soon!
Jerry Goldsmith: A Personal Reminiscence
TNG20: It Was Twenty Years Ago Today (December 1987)
EDITOR'S PICK: Suzie Plakson - "Good Luck Charm" CD
Etchstar Customized iPod nano Giveaway
ASK KATE: Trekkies, Trekkers, Which Is It?
POLL: Which TNG "gift" would you like this holiday season?

Other Random Cool Sites
Ars Technica

Microsoft trains next-gen coders with XNA's Kodu
Report: Gmail about one-third as expensive as hosted e-mail
Open source Mono framework brings C# to iPhone and Wii
Resurrection on video: hands on with the Palm pré
CCIA to Obama: Net neutrality to be an innovation engine
It's the paradigm, stupid: hands-on with OQO Model 2+
Linux-based HP Mini Mi ships with command line disabled
Palm strikes back with new OS, pré handset at CES
IT group: stimulus money needed for broadband, smart grid
Microsoft keynote highlights: Windows 7, Live, and more
Verizon offers content providers cheap access to its network
Consumers Union wants digital TV transition postponed
DOCSIS 3.0 laggard Charter files patent suit against Verizon
CES 2009: Live announcements from Sony Keynote
Macworld.Ars: Day 2 roundup
Patent Office presses rewind on broad digital music patent
Forecasting space weather and its economic impact
Students, law prof want RIAA trial live and online
CES.Ars: Live blog of Microsoft keynote
OQO launches world's smallest Vista PC with OLED screen
[H]ardOCP News/Article Feed

DRM-Free iTunes Store to Haunt Apple?
Microsoft Security Bulletin Advance Notification for January
Gaming News
AMD Announces Fusion Render Cloud
Yahoo Considering Decker For CEO
IE8 is Coming, IE8 Blocker Tool Already Out
GeForce 181.20 Drivers
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 295 Review Round-Up
Seagate FreeAgent Theater HD Media Player
Delete 10 Facebook Friends For A Free Whopper
BFGTech GeForce GTX 295
[H]ardware Round-Up
Corsair's TEC Memory Cooler
6 Year Old Drives Self to School, GTA Blamed
Lenovo and Dell Cutting Jobs
BFGTech GeForce GTX 295
AMD Phenom II X4 Model 940 Black Edition Processor
NF200 "True" 3-Way SLI Preliminary Results
EVGA X58 3X SLI Motherboard
XFX GeForce GTX 260 Black Edition
ASUS P6T6 WS Revolution
Gigabyte EX58-Extreme
Gigabyte EX58-UD5
Corsair TX850W Power Supply
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 295 Preview
Grand Theft Auto IV Gameplay Performance and IQ
Enermax Revolution85+ 1050W
FarCry 2 DX9 vs. DX10 Image Quality
ASUS M3A78-T Mobo - 790GX Chipset
Tagan BZ 1300W PSU
Slashdot

The Technology Behind the Magic Yellow Line
6-Year-Old Says Grand Theft Auto Taught Him To Drive
Attempt To "Digitalize" Beatles Goes Sour
The Inexact Science of Carbon Neutrality
Panasonic Working On 2-Terabyte SD Cards
More Brains Needed
Obama Recommends Delay In Digital TV Switch
Lexus To Start Spamming Car Buyers In Their Cars
Ballmer Sets Loose Windows 7 Public Beta At CES
Asus Reveals the Eee Keyboard
Sunday Evening, the New Web Rush Hour
Twitter Hack Details Revealed
The 2008 Linux and Free Software Timeline
NVIDIA Offers 3D Glasses For the Masses
Blu-ray Update Sent To User Via Credit Card Records


Want our headlines on your site? You can snag our RSS file and go to town. (RDF/RSS parser sold separately.) All site content © and owned by its author - for the full skinny, read the legal disclaimers bit.