bureau42.com      

bureau42.com email
Check your mail, or get a free address

Add to Google

part of the everyone.net Entertainment Network

Dreamhost Web Hosting

Problems with the site? Comments? Questions? Let us know!

 
welcome to bureau42.com
 
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles-- Review: "Self Made Man"
posted December 2, 11:59 am by Timeshredder

Category: TV Series

This "CSI: Terminator" episode showcases the acting talents of Summer Glau and Thomas Dekker-- with very different results.


Read more... ( 9 comments already posted ) | ( 3358 bytes in body ) | ( Post a comment )


<< Heroes Discussion: "The Eclipse, Part Two"  | Post a comment | Fringe Discussion: "Safe" >>

Title: "Self Made Man"

Cast and Crew

Director: Holly Dale
Writer: Toni Graphia

Summer Glau as Cameron Philips
Lena Heady as Sarah Connor
Thomas Dekker as John Connor
Leven Rambin as Riley
Billy Lush as Eric
Todd Stashwick as Myron Stark
Brian Austin Green as Derek Reese
Garret Dillahunt as Cromartie
Shirley Manson as Catherine Weaver
Richard T. Jones as James Ellison
Dean Winters as Charley Dixon

Synopsis

While the John-Riley relationship continues to develop, we learn what Cameron has been doing during her sleepless nights—- and we discover a mystery involving a Terminator who found himself in the 1920s.

High Point

I liked the relationship between Cameron and Eric. Summer Glau does an impressive job of conveying her character's oddness and isolation, in ways both humorous and touching. She's emotionally detached and pragmatic, but not in a psychopathic way. We see here the potential for real feelings. Billy Lush plays off her well. He's obviously disturbed but intrigued (a stance that could have been developed further), and I liked his delivery of the "Silver Nitrate" speech.

However, they find the correct information very easily.

Low Point

One expects that the show would include a teen love story, but I'm not buying this one. The depiction of teenage culture seems fake, the dialogue, uneven, and the chemistry, somewhat wanting.

The Scores

Originality: 4/6 The collage-approach better suits a written story (where it frequently has been used), and the out-of-hand dismissal of the web as a source of information on Stark seems heavy-handed (likely, some records would exist online). This nevertheless represents an original approach for the series.

Effects: 5/6. What effects they had worked fine.

Story: 4/6. I liked the solution to this mystery, but every use of time-travel raises the same questions about the series' premise. It seems that, with the ability to travel time, the future adversaries take a very pedestrian approach to achieving their ends. Of course, if the show really developed this angle, it would quickly resemble Desmond Warzel's "Everybody Kills Hitler...."

The writing and pacing of this episode created disconnections.

Acting: 5/6. See "High" and "Low" Points.

Production: 5/6.

Emotional response: 5/6.

Overall: 5/6.

"Self Made Man" receives 33/42.



 Comments

Summer
posted by Jethro on December 2, 1:31 pm
Summer Glau is doing an excellent job. I really hope she doesn't get typecast and gets to expand her acting vocabulary in the future.

I used to like the Riley character, and I think the girl playing her was doing a good job, too, but I'm not very happy with the direction they took with her.

I'm still enjoying the show.

reply to this

This was a kind review :)
posted by joe__gee on December 2, 3:13 pm
Is the series growing on you, Timeshredder? :)

Anyways, I like the way that we're learning about Cameron's independence from the Connors. We knew that she had her own agenda, now we're seeing it. Who was the politician she was protecting? What does he do, or not do?

As for her ability to "feel", we were shown a character that would tug at the sympathies of most humans -- Cameron's reaction was autistic at best. On a human scale she demonstrated all of the compassion of a detached scientist studying a lab animal. I don't think many machines (besides Skynet) will develop true feelings in the Terminator 'verse.

The two regular Terminatrix (cool word) characters seem to be like "Republican" and "Democrat" machines. Both of them represent opposite sides of a struggle, but quite frequently their actions put them in a central murky grey area that is indeterminate to outside observers.

Watching them, I wonder (in a good way) where this is all going. Thankfully I trust the writers of this series a bit more than I trust those over on Heroes. John will not die and resurrect every other episode. Sarah will not waver in her dedication to her son. Cameron will not turn into an angst-ridden vacuous teenager. Or at least I have high hopes these things will not happen without damned good justification.

Oh, and after this episode I'd like to see the character Riley hollowed out and turned into a T-888 skinjob like Cameron. I do not like her any more. Good actress, though.

-Joe

P.S. I like how this series handles time travel: they acknowledge it and avoid mentioning the paradox conundrums that were so much fodder for Star Trek. It just is.

reply to this

Re: This was a kind review :)
posted by Timeshredder on December 2, 3:41 pm

Is the series growing on you, Timeshredder? :)


Next to Fringe and this season's sorry excuse for Heroes, this is frikkin' genius.

reply to this

3 dots
posted by redshadow on December 2, 5:11 pm
I am guessing that those 3 dots now have a meaning.Spoiler If terminators use a 3 star formation to calculate the date, perhaps those dots are a date? Was it a waring about the new Judgment Day or some other big event?

reply to this

Re: 3 dots
posted by valen1260 on December 3, 8:13 am
I am guessing that those 3 dots now have a meaning.
I don't think a human, especially one in the throes of death, could make anything exact enough to represent an actual date, and using them just to mean "a date" is pointless. Nice idea, though.

reply to this

Season One
posted by chad on December 3, 1:47 am
Just watched the first season on DVD (I don't watch live TV much) and really liked it. Bummer that it was only 9 episodes. Looking forward to season 2.


____________________
Check out Chad's News

reply to this

Suspension of disbelief
posted by Daemonik on December 3, 5:07 am
Story: 4/6. I liked the solution to this mystery, but every use of time-travel raises the same questions about the series' premise. It seems that, with the ability to travel time, the future adversaries take a very pedestrian approach to achieving their ends. Of course, if the show really developed this angle, it would quickly resemble Desmond Warzel's "Everybody Kills Hitler...."


Honestly, the whole idea of time travel and cyborg terminators is really kind of lame if you want to dissect the premise, so it's best not to think about it and just enjoy the show for what it is.

I don't mean lame in not cool, cyborg killing machines are generally always cool, just not logical. There are so many more effective and efficient ways for Skynet to ensure humanities extinction than cyborg hunter/killer machines. Viral plagues, environmental destruction, build itself a spaceship and enjoy the view from Saturn as it hurls asteroids into the Earth's crust...

reply to this

A good (jonbar) point
posted by Timeshredder on December 3, 5:36 am

Honestly, the whole idea of time travel and cyborg terminators is really kind of lame if you want to dissect the premise, so it's best not to think about it and just enjoy the show for what it is.


I can try to construct an argument based on the idea that major disruptions would be identified as the history-altering events they are and stopped by the other side's time-travellers, whereas small ones (such as the killing of the public figure in this episode) would go unnoticed and therefore have the necessary effect, but even that doesn't hold up particularly well. And since everyone recognizes John Connor as the series' John Barr, killing him no longer constitutes a minor disruption.

The acting and other elements can carry this show, but I really wish they would have worked something out to make the premise slightly logical.

Well, until the Doctor shows up....


reply to this

Re: A good (jonbar) point
posted by Karrde712 on December 3, 9:48 am
I can try to construct an argument based on the idea that major disruptions would be identified as the history-altering events they are and stopped by the other side's time-travellers, whereas small ones (such as the killing of the public figure in this episode) would go unnoticed and therefore have the necessary effect, but even that doesn't hold up particularly well. And since everyone recognizes John Connor as the series' John Barr, killing him no longer constitutes a minor disruption.


You might be looking at this wrong. Killing John Connor would disrupt things in such a way that other time travelers would intervene. But suppose that this is not Skynet's goal? Perhaps the very act of hunting John is providing sufficient distraction to ensure that the human resistance keeps sending their best agents back to defend him.

Possibly as well, Skynet has calculated that by forcing John to stay on the move and keep dodging Skynet's forces, he will never stay in one place long enough to learn the tactics and skills necessary to be a real leader in the future.

Skynet doesn't have to kill John to render him useless to the resistance.

reply to this



<< Heroes Discussion: "The Eclipse, Part Two"  | Post a comment | Fringe Discussion: "Safe" >>
 
Current Headlines
People's Choice Awards Results (1)
Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season Eight Review - Issue 21 (0)
Secret Invasion / War of Kings Review - "Secret Invasion: War of Kings" (0)
Novel Review: The Stars My Destination (5)
Weekly Comics Discussion - January 7, 2008 (0)
Matt Smith IS The Doctor (9)
Weekly Digital Disc Picks - January 6, 2008 (0)
Weekend Review - "Dr. Horrible's Sing-A-Long Blog" (6)

Other SF Sites
Sci-Fi Storm

Peek at new <i>Star Trek</i> tech
<i>Tron</i> gets young lead actor
SCI FI Wire gets redesign
The new Doctor is...Matt Smith
New Doctor Who actor chosen -announced Saturday
Terry Farrell (of DS9) returns to the stage
<i>Terminator</i> joins the National Film Registry
Fox has rights to <i>Watchman</i>, according to judge
Disney says bon voyage to <i>Narnia: Treader</i>
<i>Babylon 5</i> music videos available online for the first time
STARTREK.COM - Headlines

Next Remastered Episode: "Tomorrow Is Yesterday"
Keep the conversation going on StarTrek.com boards
Okuda Logo for New Lunar Lander Unveiled
"InAlienable" Premieres, "Of Gods & Men" Soon!
Jerry Goldsmith: A Personal Reminiscence
TNG20: It Was Twenty Years Ago Today (December 1987)
EDITOR'S PICK: Suzie Plakson - "Good Luck Charm" CD
Etchstar Customized iPod nano Giveaway
ASK KATE: Trekkies, Trekkers, Which Is It?
POLL: Which TNG "gift" would you like this holiday season?

Other Random Cool Sites
Ars Technica

Microsoft trains next-gen coders with XNA's Kodu
Report: Gmail about one-third as expensive as hosted e-mail
Open source Mono framework brings C# to iPhone and Wii
Resurrection on video: hands on with the Palm pré
CCIA to Obama: Net neutrality to be an innovation engine
It's the paradigm, stupid: hands-on with OQO Model 2+
Linux-based HP Mini Mi ships with command line disabled
Palm strikes back with new OS, pré handset at CES
IT group: stimulus money needed for broadband, smart grid
Microsoft keynote highlights: Windows 7, Live, and more
Verizon offers content providers cheap access to its network
Consumers Union wants digital TV transition postponed
DOCSIS 3.0 laggard Charter files patent suit against Verizon
CES 2009: Live announcements from Sony Keynote
Macworld.Ars: Day 2 roundup
Patent Office presses rewind on broad digital music patent
Forecasting space weather and its economic impact
Students, law prof want RIAA trial live and online
CES.Ars: Live blog of Microsoft keynote
OQO launches world's smallest Vista PC with OLED screen
[H]ardOCP News/Article Feed

DRM-Free iTunes Store to Haunt Apple?
Microsoft Security Bulletin Advance Notification for January
Gaming News
AMD Announces Fusion Render Cloud
Yahoo Considering Decker For CEO
IE8 is Coming, IE8 Blocker Tool Already Out
GeForce 181.20 Drivers
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 295 Review Round-Up
Seagate FreeAgent Theater HD Media Player
Delete 10 Facebook Friends For A Free Whopper
BFGTech GeForce GTX 295
[H]ardware Round-Up
Corsair's TEC Memory Cooler
6 Year Old Drives Self to School, GTA Blamed
Lenovo and Dell Cutting Jobs
BFGTech GeForce GTX 295
AMD Phenom II X4 Model 940 Black Edition Processor
NF200 "True" 3-Way SLI Preliminary Results
EVGA X58 3X SLI Motherboard
XFX GeForce GTX 260 Black Edition
ASUS P6T6 WS Revolution
Gigabyte EX58-Extreme
Gigabyte EX58-UD5
Corsair TX850W Power Supply
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 295 Preview
Grand Theft Auto IV Gameplay Performance and IQ
Enermax Revolution85+ 1050W
FarCry 2 DX9 vs. DX10 Image Quality
ASUS M3A78-T Mobo - 790GX Chipset
Tagan BZ 1300W PSU
Slashdot

The Technology Behind the Magic Yellow Line
6-Year-Old Says Grand Theft Auto Taught Him To Drive
Attempt To "Digitalize" Beatles Goes Sour
The Inexact Science of Carbon Neutrality
Panasonic Working On 2-Terabyte SD Cards
More Brains Needed
Obama Recommends Delay In Digital TV Switch
Lexus To Start Spamming Car Buyers In Their Cars
Ballmer Sets Loose Windows 7 Public Beta At CES
Asus Reveals the Eee Keyboard
Sunday Evening, the New Web Rush Hour
Twitter Hack Details Revealed
The 2008 Linux and Free Software Timeline
NVIDIA Offers 3D Glasses For the Masses
Blu-ray Update Sent To User Via Credit Card Records


Want our headlines on your site? You can snag our RSS file and go to town. (RDF/RSS parser sold separately.) All site content © and owned by its author - for the full skinny, read the legal disclaimers bit.